nav emailalert searchbtn searchbox tablepage yinyongbenwen piczone journalimg journalInfo journalinfonormal searchdiv searchzone qikanlogo popupnotification paper paperNew
2012, 02, v.3 85-98
新生儿复苏培训降低新生儿死亡率的效能分析:文献综述,meta分析与Delphi法的应用
基金项目(Foundation):
邮箱(Email):
DOI: 10.19757/j.cnki.issn1674-7763.2012.02.009
摘要:

[背景]全球每年13600万新生儿中,约1000万需要外界的帮助才能建立自主呼吸,每年有约814000例新生儿死亡是由分娩相关足月儿死亡(以往定义为"出生窒息")所导致的。目前尚缺乏关于新生儿复苏培训降低新生儿死亡率效能的系统性评价。[目的]对在医院和社区层面开展的快速评估及初步刺激、基本的复苏措施这两种新生儿复苏培训干预方法在降低足月新生儿分娩相关死亡率("出生窒息")、早产相关并发症死亡率这两个生命指标方面的效能进行评价。[方法]采用系统综述的方法,检索并筛选符合标准的新生儿复苏培训研究文献。采用GRADE方法对文献的质量进行评价。对符合要求的文件进行Meta分析。对数据质量较低的文献采用专家咨询法估计效能大小。[结果]通过文献检索筛选了24篇新生儿复苏培训干预研究(20篇观察性研究,2篇半试验研究,2篇随机对照研究)。对其中3篇文献进行Meta分析结果显示,以医院为基础的新生儿复苏培训可使分娩相关足月儿死亡降低30%(RR=0.70,95%CI0.59~0.84);文献中涉及早产儿死亡率效能的数据质量不高,因此采用专家咨询法进行估计。以社区为基础的新生儿复苏培训干预研究具有较高的异质性,复苏培训通常是一系列培训包的一部分,且对早产儿和足月儿的定义标准不一致。专家咨询法估计结果显示,新生儿快速评估和初步刺激可使分娩相关新生儿死亡、早产儿死亡均降低10%;以医院为基础的培训可使早产儿死亡进一步降低10%,以社区为基础的培训可使分娩相关足月儿死亡率进一步降低20%,早产儿死亡率进一步降低5%。[结论]新生儿复苏培训在医院层面可以使足月新生儿分娩相关死亡率降低30%,然而中低收入水平的国家培训覆盖率仍较低。专家咨询法估计新生儿复苏培训在社区层面降低足月儿及早产儿死亡率的效能较小。需要对新生儿复苏培训的效果、成本、实施策略等进行更深入的研究与评价。

关键词:
Abstract:

KeyWords:
参考文献

[1]Wall SN,Lee AC,Niermeyer S,et al.Neonatal resuscita-tion in low-resource settings:what,who,and how to o-vercome challenges to scale up[J].Int J Gynaecol Ob-stet,2009,107(Suppl1):S47-62-S63-44.

[2]Deorari AK,Paul VK,Singh M,Vidyasagar D:Impact of education and training on neonatal resuscitation prac-tices in14teaching hospitals in India[J].Ann Trop Pae-diatr,2001,21(1):29-33.

[3]Zhu XY,Fang HQ,Zeng SP,Li YM,Lin HL,Shi SZ:The impact of the neonatal resuscitation program guide-lines(NRPG)on the neonatal mortality in a hospital in Zhuhai,China[J].Singapore Med J,1997,38(11):485-487.

[4]Organization WH:The World Health Report2005-make every mother and child count.Geneva,Switzerland:World Health Organization,2005.

[5]Bang AT,Bang RA,Baitule SB,Reddy HM,Deshmukh MD:Management of birth asphyxia in home deliveries in rural Gadchiroli:the effect of two types of birth attendants and of resuscitating with mouth-to-mouth,tube-mask or bag-mask[J].J Perinatol,2005,25(Suppl1):S82-91.

[6]Textbook of Neonatal Resuscitation[M].American Acad-emy of Pediatrics,2006.

[7]Lawn JE,Lee AC,Kinney M,Sibley L,Carlo WA,PaulVK,Pattinson R,Darmstadt GL:Two million intrapar-tum-related stillbirths and neonatal deaths:where,why,and what can be done[J]Int J Gynaecol Obstet,2009,107(Suppl1):S5-18-S19.

[8]Child Health Epidemiology Reference Group of WHO and UNICEF,Black RE,C S,Johnson HL,Lawn JE,Ru-dan I,Bassani DG,Jha P,Campbell H,Walker CF,Cibulskis R,Eisele T,Liu L,Mathers C:Global,re-gional,and national causes of child mortality in2008:a systematic analysis[J].Lancet,2010,375(9730):1969-1987.

[9]Lawn J,Shibuya K,Stein C:No cry at birth:global esti-mates of intrapartum stillbirths and intrapartum-related neonatal deaths[J].Bull World Health Organ,2005,83(6):409-417.

[10]Lawn JE,Cousens S,Zupan J:4million neonatal deaths:when?Where?Why[J]Lancet,2005,365(9462):891-900.

[11]Perlman JM,Risser R:Cardiopulmonary resuscitation in the delivery room.Associated clinical events[J].Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med,1995,149(1):20-25.

[12]Tan A,Schulze A,O’Donnell CP,Davis PG:Air versus oxygen for resuscitation of infants at birth[J].Cochrane Database Syst Rev,2005,2:CD002273.

[13]Dawson JA,Kamlin CO,Wong C,te Pas AB,O’Donnell CP,Donath SM,Davis PG,Morley CJ:Oxygen saturation and heart rate during delivery room resuscita-tion of infants<30weeks’gestation with air or100%oxygen[J].Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed,2009,94(2):F87-91.

[14]Wang CL,Anderson C,Leone TA,Rich W,Govin-daswami B,Finer NN:Resuscitation of preterm neonates by using room air or100%oxygen[J].Pediatrics,2008,121(6):1083-1089.

[15]Escrig R,Arruza L,Izquierdo I,Villar G,Saenz P,Gi-meno A,Moro M,Vento M:Achievement of targeted sat-uration values in extremely low gestational age neonates resuscitated with low or high oxygen concentrations:a prospective,randomized trial[J].Pediatrics,2008,121(5):875-881.

[16]Newton O,English M:Newborn resuscitation:defining best practice for low-income settings[J].Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg,2006,100(10):899-908.

[17]Singhal N,Bhutta ZA:Newborn resuscitation in resource-limited settings[J].Semin Fetal Neonatal Med,2008,13(6):432-439.

[18]Singhal N,Niermeyer S:Neonatal resuscitation where re-sources are limited[J].Clin Perinatol,2006,33(1):219-228-x-xi.

[19]Lawn JE,Manandhar A,Haws RA,Darmstadt GL:Re-ducing one million child deaths from birth asphyxia–a survey of health systems gaps and priorities[J].Health Res Policy Syst,2007,5:4.

[20]Organization WH:Basic Newborn Resuscitation,a practi-cal guide.World Health Organization;Organization WH1997.

[21]CHERG Review Groups on Intervention Effects,Walker N,Fischer-Walker C,Bryce J,Bahl R,Cousens S:Standards for CHERG reviews of intervention effects on child survival[J].Int J Epidemiol,2010,39(Supple-ment1):i21-31.

[22]Plosky W,Stover J,Winfrey B:The Lives Saved Tool:A computer program for making child and maternal survival projections.US Fund for Unicef,2009.

[23]Darmstadt GL,Bhutta ZA,Cousens S,Adam T,Walker N,de Bernis L:Evidence-based,cost-effective interven-tions:how many newborn babies can we save[J].Lan-cet,2005,365(9463):977-988.

[24]Guyatt GH,Oxman AD,Kunz R,Jaeschke R,Helfand M,Liberati A,Vist GE,Schunemann HJ:Incorporating considerations of resources use into grading recommenda-tions[J].BMJ,2008,336(7654):1170-1173.

[25]Palsy ATFoNEaC:Neonatal Encephalopathy and Cerebral Palsy:Defining the Pathogenesis and Pathophysiology.Washington DC:ACOG,2003.

[26]MacLennan A:A Template for defining a causal relation between acute intrapartum events and cerebral palsy:in-ternational consensus statement[J].Br Med J,1999,319:1054-1059.

[27]Committee on Fetus and Newborn AAoP,Committee on Obstetric Practice,American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists:Use and Abuse of the Apgar Score[J].Pediatrics,1996,98:141-142.

[28]Pediatrics AAo:Use and Abuse of the Apgar Score[J].Pediatrics,1996,98(1):141-142.

[29]Lawn JE,Wilczynska-Ketende K,Cousens SN:Estima-ting the causes of4million neonatal deaths in the year2000[J].Int J Epidemiol,2006,35(3):706-718.

[30]Extended Wigglesworth Classification.[http://www.cemach.org.uk/getattachment/9adc102a-a2e5-4cb1-8de7-f45b246a6083/Extended-Wigglesworth-Classifica-tion.aspx].

[31]Marlow N:Do we need an Apgar score[J].Arch Dis Child,1992,67:765-767.

[32]Dalkey N:DELPHI.Organization R,1967,10.

[33]Jeffery H,Kocova M,Tozija F,Gjorgiev D,Pop-Lazaro-va M,Foster K,Polverino J,Hill D:The impact of evi-dence based education on a perinatal capacity-building in-itiative in Macedonia[J].Medical Education,2004,38:435-447.

[34]Sen A,Mahalanabis D,Singh AK,Som TK,Bandyo-padhyay S:Impact of a district level sick newborn care u-nit on neonatal mortality rate:2-year follow-up[J].J Perinatol,2009,29(2):150-155.

[35]Mufti P,Setna F,Nazir K:Early neonatal mortality:effects of interventions on survival of low birth babies weighing1000-2000g[J].J Pak Med Assoc,2006,56(4):174-176.

[36]Berglund A,L-C H,Bacci A,Blyumina A,Lindmark G:Successful implementation of evidence-based routines in Ukrainian maternities[J].Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand,2010,89(2):230-237.

[37]Draycott T,Sibanda T,Owen L,Akande V,Winter C,Reading S,Whitelaw A:Does training in obstetric emer-gencies improve neonatal outcome[J].BJOG,2006,113(2):177-182.

[38]Carlo WA,M E,Chomba E,Chakraborty H,Hartwell T,Harris H,Lincetto O,Wright LL:Newborn Care Training of Midwives and Neonatal and Perinatal Mortality Rates in a Developing Country[J].Pediatrics,2010,[Epub].

[39]Chomba E,McClure EM,Wright LL,Carlo WA,Chakraborty H,Harris H:Effect of WHO newborn care training on neonatal mortality by education[J].Ambul Pediatr,2008,8(5):300-304.

[40]Tholpadi S,Sudhindra B,Bhutani V:Neonatal Resusci-tation Program in Rural Kerela India to Reduce Infant Mortality Attributed to Perinatal Asphyxia[J].J Perina-tol,2000,20:460.

[41]Wang H,Y H,Niermeyer S:Asphyxia Decreases in10Provinces of the Peoples Republic of China After Training with the Neonatal Resuscitation Program.Pediatric Aca-demic Societies:May2008Honolulu HI,2008.

[42]Duran R,Aladag N,Vatansever U,Sut N,Acunas B:The impact of Neonatal Resuscitation Program courses on mortality and morbidity of newborn infants with perinatal asphyxia[J].Brain Dev,2008,30(1):43-46.

[43]Boo NY:Neonatal resuscitation programme in Malaysia:an eight-year experience[J].Singapore Med J,2009,50(2):152-159.

[44]Vakrilova L,Elleau C,Sluncheva B:French-Bulgarian program“Resuscitation of the newborn in a delivery room"–results and perspectives[J].Akush Ginekol(Sofiia),2005,44(3):35-40.

[45]Zhu X:Neonatal resuscitation[J].World Health Forum,1993,14(3):289-290.

[46]Opiyo N,W F,Govedi F,Fegan G,Wasunna A,Eng-lish M:Effect of newborn resuscitation training on health worker practices in Pumwani Hospital[J].Kenya PLoS One,2008,3(2):e1599.

[47]Baqui AH,Darmstadt GL,Williams EK,Kumar V,Ki-ran TU,Panwar D,Srivastava VK,Ahuja R,Black RE,Santosham M:Rates,timing and causes of neonatal deaths in rural India:implications for neonatal health pro-grammes[J].Bull World Health Organ,2006,84(9):706-713.

[48]Edmond KM,Quigley MA,Zandoh C,Danso S,Hurt C,Owusu Agyei S,Kirkwood BR:Aetiology of stillbirths and neonatal deaths in rural Ghana:implications for health programming in developing countries[J].Paediatr Perinat Epidemiol,2008,22(5):430-437.

[49]O’Hare BA,N M,Southall DP:A pilot study to deter-mine if nurses trained in basic neonatal resuscitation would impact the outcome of neonates delivered in Kam-pala,Uganda[J].J Trop Pediatr,2006,52:376-379.

[50]Pratinidhi A,Shah U,Shrotri A,Bodhani N:Risk-ap-proach strategy in neonatal care[J].Bull World Health Organ,1986,64(2):291-297.

[51]Daga SR,Daga AS,Dighole RV,Patil RP,Dhinde HL:Rural neonatal care:Dahanu experience[J].Indian Ped-iatr,1992,29(2):189-193.

[52]Carlo WA,Goudar SS,Jehan I,Chomba E,Tshefu A,Garces A,Parida S,Althabe F,McClure EM,Derman RJ,et al:Newborn-care training and perinatal mortality in developing countries[J].N Engl J Med,2010,362(7):614-623.

[53]Gill C,Mazala G,Guerina N,Kasimba J,Knapp A,Mulenga C,MacLeod W,Mazimba A,Mirochnick M,Sabin L,et al:Effect of training traditional birth attend-ants on neonatal mortality(Lufwanyama Neonatal Survival Project):randomised controlled study[J].Br Med J,2011,342:d346.

[54]Ariawan I:Reducing Birth Asphyxia Through the Bidan di Desa Program in Cirebon,Indonesia.Jakarta,Indone-sia:PATH;2006,1-18.

[55]Kumar R:Effectiveness of training traditional birth at-tendants for management of asphyxia neonatorum using re-suscitation equipment[J].Prenat Neonat Med,1998,3:255-260.

[56]Palme-Kilander C:Methods of resuscitation in low-Apgar score newborn infants–a national survey[J].Acta Pae-diatr,1992,81:739-744.

[57]Carlo WA,W L,Chomba E,McClure EM,Carlo ME,Bann CM,Collins M,Harris H:Educational impact of the neonatal resuscitation program in low-risk delivery centers in a developing country[J].J Pediatr,2009,154:504-508.

[58]Wall SN,Lee AC,Niermeyer S,English M,Keenan W,Carlo W,Bhutta ZA,Bang A,Narayanan I,Ariawan I,et al:Neonatal resuscitation in lowresource settings:What,who,and how to overcome challenges to scale up[J].Int J Gynaecol Obstet,2009.

[59]Stanton C,Lawn JE,Rahman H,Wilczynska-Ketende K,Hill K:Stillbirth rates:delivering estimates in190countries[J].Lancet,2006,367(9521):1487-1494.

[60]Spector JM,Daga S:Preventing those so-called stillbirths[J].Bull World Health Organ,2008,86(4):315-316.

[61]Harrington DJ,Redman CW,Moulden M,Greenwood CE:The long-term outcome in surviving infants with Ap-gar zero at10minutes:a systematic review of the litera-ture and hospital-based cohort[J].Am J Obstet Gynecol,2007,196(5):463e461-465.

[62]Laptook AR,Shankaran S,Ambalavanan N,Carlo WA,McDonald SA,Higgins RD,Das A:Outcome of term in-fants using apgar scores at10minutes following hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy[J].Pediatrics,2009,124(6):1619-1626.

[63]Nelson K,Simonsen SE,Henry E,Wilder S,Rose NC:The Apparently Stillborn Infant:Risk Factors,Incidence,and Neonatal Outcome[J].Am J Perinatol,2010.

[64]Jain L,Ferre C,Vidyasagar D,Nath S,Sheftel D:Car-diopulmonary resuscitation of apparently stillborn infants:Survival and long-term outcome[J].J Pediatr,1991,118(5):778-782.

[65]Lawn JE,Yakoob MY,Haws RA,Soomro T,Darmstadt GL,Bhutta ZA:3.2million stillbirths:epidemiology and overview of the evidence review[J].BMC Pregnancy Childbirth,2009,9(Suppl1):S2.

[66]Lawn JE,Gravett MG,Nunes TM,Rubens CE,Stanton C:Global report on preterm birth and stillbirth(1of7):definitions,description of the burden and opportunities to improve data[J].BMC Pregnancy Childbirth10(Suppl1):S1.

[67]Lawn JE,Osrin D,Adler A,Cousens S:Four million neonatal deaths:counting and attribution of cause of death[J].Paediatr Perinat Epidemiol,2008,22(5):410-416.

[68]http://www.helpingbabiesbreathe.org.

[69]Lawn J,Kinney M,Lee AC,Chopra M,Donnay F,Paul V,Bateman M,Bhutta Z,Darmstadt G:Reducing intra-partum-related deaths and disability:can the health sys-tem deliver[J].Int J Gynecol Obstet,2009.

[70]Hofmeyr GJ,Haws RA,Bergstrom S,Lee AC,Okong P,Darmstadt GL,Mullany LC,Oo EK,Lawn JE:Obstetric care in low-resource settings:what,who,and how to o-vercome challenges to scale up[J].Int J Gynaecol Ob-stet,2009,107(Suppl1):S21-44-S44-25.

[71]Lee AC,Cousens S,Darmstadt GL,Blencowe H,Pattin-son R,Moran N,Hofmeyr GJ,Haws R,Bhutta SZ,Lawn J:Care during labor and birth for the prevention of intrapartum-related neonatal deaths:a systematic review and Delphi estimation of mortality effect.BMC Public Health2010,Submitted for publication.

[72]Bang AT,B R,Baitule SB,Reddy MH,Deshmukh MD:Effect of home-based neonatal care and management of sepsis on neonatal mortality:field trial in rural India[J].Lancet,1999,354:1955-1961.

[73]Azad K,Barnett S,Banerjee B,Shaha S,Khan K,RegoAR,Barua S,Flatman D,Pagel C,Prost A,Ellis M,Costello A:Effect of scaling up women’s groups on birth outcomes in three rural districts in Bangladesh:a cluster-randomised controlled trial[J].Lancet,2010,375(9721):1193-202.

基本信息:

DOI:10.19757/j.cnki.issn1674-7763.2012.02.009

中图分类号:R722.1

引用信息:

[1]Anne CC Lee,Simon Cousens,Stephen N Wall,等.新生儿复苏培训降低新生儿死亡率的效能分析:文献综述,meta分析与Delphi法的应用[J].中国妇幼卫生杂志,2012,3(02):85-98.DOI:10.19757/j.cnki.issn1674-7763.2012.02.009.

发布时间:

2012-03-20

出版时间:

2012-03-20

检 索 高级检索